Dr. Strange(Love), or, How I learned to stop worrying and love Magic 

By: Jesse Lane


It seems like the most contentious topic in Magic The Gathering discourse for the past 5 years has been Universes Beyond (UB). From The Walking Dead, to Lord of the Rings, to Marvel, I don’t think any media franchise is ineligible to be printed on cardboard at this point. Like most long-time MTG players, I have had a lot of mixed feelings on UB – when it is a franchise I personally love, like Warhammer 40,000 or Final Fantasy XIII, it is the greatest thing to ever happen to the game. On the flip side, when they incorporate media that I don’t vibe with, like Fortnite (sorry gamers), it feels like WOTC is, well, Fortnite-ifying my favorite TCG.



There is no doubt that MTG has seen a very strong growth trend since the dawn of UB. With each new set that strays from the traditional Magic canon, more people are brought into the game. Naturally, there have been several downsides to this as well. We all know the release cadence is, frankly, painful for the most invested players and LGS’s alike. In addition, many of the old-head players I talk to feel fairly embittered by the new IP-crossover cards becoming legal in so many formats. Personally, I actually enjoy a majority of UB cards/sets – seeing what made the cut, how the IP translates mechanically, and appreciating the art – but I would still like to play some games that are more canonically MTG, harkening back to the days of slinging spells as a planeswalker.



So what is the solution? UB has become legal and thoroughly embedded in Standard, Commander, and most other common formats. To me, the answer to this puzzle is just that, more formats! Now before you get upset thinking you have to build another deck for another new format, hear me out here. From nearly the very beginning, MTG has never been a monolith. As early as the days of Type 1 and Type 2, there has been diversity in the way people engage with the game. Today that trend continues between Commander players, Standard players, Modern players, and so on. People are very capable of choosing the format that suits them best, so it fascinates me that they won’t do the same thing with card pools.


One of the things that really got me thinking of alternative formats, was actually a different TCG entirely. Arguably the greatest format in any card game is Edison (I’m a little biased).  Edison is a unique format in YuGiOh that contains only the playable cards that were available at SJC Edison, a 2010 championship. This is interesting to the UB discussion, as Edison was partially created as a response to YuGiOh cards becoming overly complex, and in some cases, completely broken. The bottom line is that a group of players decided they didn’t like new things happening with the game, and decided to freeze YGO exactly how they liked it. What is stopping anyone from doing the same in MTG?


Many formats in Magic follow a formula that excludes very old cards and includes ones going forward from a particular point (i.e. Modern and Pioneer). However, if that doesn't float your boat, I would urge players to explore or create the formats that they want to play! If you are feeling like you want to engage in a more classic MTG experience, I assure you there are others that share that sentiment.  If you want to explore a format in this style, here is a tip: the last full MTG set to be released before The Walking Dead kicked off the whole UB trend was Zendikar Rising. Haters may not want to admit it, but Zendikar Rising is a fantastic set, and if you told me you made a format that was any card released from Zendikar Rising or before (and the ban list was reasonable, of course) I would be so thrilled to sling some spells in the old school style.


New players coming into MTG via UB is a great thing. It adds fresh perspectives and players to the game we all love, helping it continue well into the future. After becoming acquainted with the game through Spiderman, these new players may find themselves interested in the existing lore in a larger way. What better way to learn the history of Magic than by playing it as it was?




With all of that said, I want to know what you think! Was there a particular Standard from the past you most enjoyed? Would you be interested in more historical formats? Have you ever considered that Core Set 2021 Standard was the greatest Standard of all time, or is that just me? Leave a comment or let’s discuss more in the Bonebox Community Discord!


Thanks for reading. :)

-Jesse


Th


Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.